Lily’s Best Weapons: Lullaby, Alternatives and Full Team Upgrade Calculations

Lullaby is Lily's signature weapon and the first option in Nanoka's version 3.8.5 recommendations. The useful numerical question is how much the supplied teams gain when Lily moves from S0R0 to S0R1: approximately 5.26% with Hsin/Suoming and 7.61% with Sigrika/Lucilla.

There is an important limit to those figures. The calculation sheet does not name the S0R0 weapon. It provides an investment comparison, not a complete Lullaby-versus-Static-Mist-versus-Thunderbolt ranking. Here is what the current data can tell you about Lily's weapon choices.

Why Lullaby fits Lily's support kit

Lullaby supplies Energy Regen, which matters to Lily's support scaling as well as her Liberation uptime. Its version 3.8.5 effects also support her healing-based rotation rather than simply increasing her personal attack damage.

At rank 1, the listed effects include a 12% Max HP increase and eight Concerto Energy after Liberation, subject to a 20-second trigger interval. Healing through Heavy Attack activates its support effects. The listed Unison benefit gives eligible teammates a 16% ATK increase, while its Echo-related benefit gives the active character 24% Echo Skill DMG Bonus under the stated conditions. The relevant effects have 30-second durations and effects of the same name do not stack.

Those conditions matter. A team that uses Unison or meaningful Echo Skill damage can make use of the corresponding parts of the weapon. It would be misleading to combine all the percentages into one unconditional damage bonus for every character.

Hsin and Suoming: full S0R0 versus S0R1 comparison

The Unison investment table holds Hsin and Suoming at S0R1 and changes Lily's investment:

• Lily S0R0: 2,740,271.796 full-team damage per rotation.
• Lily S0R1: 2,884,326.379 full-team damage per rotation.
• Absolute difference: 144,054.583 damage.
• Relative increase from S0R0 to S0R1: approximately 5.26%.

The S0R0 row is approximately 95.01% of the S0R1 result. That does not mean the upgrade is 4.99%: 4.99 percentage points is the gap on a chart that sets S0R1 to 100%, whereas 5.26% measures the gain relative to the lower S0R0 starting value.

Hsin, Suoming and Lily all contribute to the total, and separate Tune Break damage is included. This percentage is not an isolated measurement of Lily's personal weapon damage.

Sigrika and Lucilla: a different team benefit

The Echo investment table uses Sigrika S0R1 and Lucilla S0R1:

• Lily S0R0: 2,317,367.641 full-team damage per rotation.
• Lily S0R1: 2,493,795.425 full-team damage per rotation.
• Absolute difference: 176,427.784 damage.
• Relative increase from S0R0 to S0R1: approximately 7.61%.

Here, the S0R0 result is approximately 92.93% of the S0R1 reference. The larger relative gain shows why Lily's weapon should be evaluated in the team you actually plan to use. It does not establish a fixed 7.61% improvement in every Echo lineup or in every other mode.

Both contexts come from the Lily (WIP) sheet labeled version 3.8.5. The team tables use 25–28 second rotations averaged over four loops. They should be treated as provisional calculations rather than measured guarantees.

Static Mist and Thunderbolt: recommendations without a numerical ranking

Nanoka lists Static Mist and Thunderbolt after Lullaby in Lily's weapon recommendations. They are legitimate options to inspect in the current guide, but that recommendation list is not a simulation output.

Neither weapon is identified as the S0R0 baseline in the supplied investment rows. There is therefore no supported percentage here for Lullaby versus Static Mist specifically, or for Lullaby versus Thunderbolt at a particular rank.

When comparing an alternative, check whether your actual build reaches the intended Energy Regen and rotation requirements. A recommendation based on a weapon's available stats and effects should remain distinct from a damage ranking produced with a fully specified build.

Signature weapon or Resonance Chains?

The same sheet provides separate S1R1 and S2R1 rows. With Hsin/Suoming, Lily S1R1 is 1.61% above S0R1 and S2R1 is 15.19% above it. With Sigrika/Lucilla, those increases are 3.69% and 12.72%.

These percentages start from a different baseline than the S0R0-to-S0R1 weapon comparison. They do not test S1 without Lullaby, so the table cannot directly settle whether S1 without the signature beats S0 with it. Adding percentages from separate rows would not produce a valid new build result.

What to take from the current weapon data

Lullaby is the best-supported signature choice in the current source recommendations, and the S0R1 teams outperform their unnamed S0R0 counterparts in both supplied contexts. The increases are approximately 5.26% for Hsin/Suoming and 7.61% for Sigrika/Lucilla.

That is useful evidence for a team-specific investment decision. A complete best-weapon ranking still needs a named baseline, exact alternative weapons and ranks, and consistent builds. Until the source provides them, use the live comparison and the linked weapon data without treating an unspecified baseline as a named competitor.